Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Laura's avatar

I’m here subscribing to you after reading this on BAR. Thank you for this optimistic and hopeful take. I often think Jesse and Katie are too careful in their pushback against woke policies/culture. I personally feel assaulted by the culture in which my kids are coming of age and on certain days I definitely am too angry to be effective. On those days I am thankful for the reasoned approach - BAR lets me laugh and calms me down.

But I’m also tired of being careful - the only way these topics will get into the mainstream conversation , given MSM, is for top-down policies like this. It is not safe for there to be so few people questioning the woke agenda. It is sneaking in and becoming codified because they don’t see through the language: “ obviously we want to be inclusive” and “I want more people to have happier lives so... equity.” The less thoughtful / more reactive parents around me are not thinking things through. The ones who are live in fear of others canceling them or their kids.

We’re need more examples of open pushback. UTAX is a hopeful project but it is too small. I am grateful to see existing universities create new heterodox spaces and programs. Very grateful.

Expand full comment
Daerandir's avatar

Congrats on the spiffy new job title! I also had some issues with Katie and Jesse's take, which rightfully got a considerable amount of push back in the comments from people like myself, with recent or current experience in public universities in the South.

I agree with a lot of your take here. On the question of a "takeover" of an existing institution like New College, I think it's an approach that I wouldn't want, except I think shaking things up at some places may be what's needed to make substantial change in the trajectory towards doctrinaire thought at so many universities. As you pointed out with the planned University of Austin (best wishes for them, in all sincerity), trying to get a new university off the ground is extremely challenging, especially, I imagine, in the case of a public school. Would take a lot of political will to found a whole new university when UCF can just add a few thousand more to the roster, not to mention competing against institutions with very established reputations.

I also have to appreciate your shout out to GMU economics. I actually spent my first two years in undergrad studying economics and poly sci at Mason. I ended up having to transfer for family reasons, but I believe I learned a ton there and the perspectives I was exposed to have helped me be a more rigorous and balanced thinker to this day, even if, like you, I don't agree with a lot of the positions of, say, Caplan and Hanson. There is so much to be said for productive disagreement, and I think that's one of the values particularly at stake in academia today. I think you make a really good point about having viewpoint diversity *between* institutions, not necessarily expecting full diversity within each particular school.

I'm not a DeSantis fan (although I think attacks on him often go too far) and definitely not Rufo, I still hope that maybe something good will come of this experiment, or something similar at other schools, especially if it could be accomplished with a wee bit less fanfare.

Expand full comment
10 more comments...

No posts